A will is a legal document that outlines an individual’s wishes, referred to as the testator (if male) or testatrix (if female), regarding the distribution of their assets after death. This document, which can only be revoked during the lifetime of its maker, plays an essential role in ensuring that the testator’s intentions are respected and carried out accordingly.
Under the Indian Succession Act of 1925, probate is defined as “A copy of a will certified under the seal of the court of competent jurisdiction with a grant of administration of the estate of the testator.” Probate serves as a legal confirmation provided by the court, certifying the authenticity of the will and granting the named executors the authority to manage and distribute the testator’s estate.
The necessity typically arises when dealing with immovable assets located across multiple states. It is an important step that confirms the will was executed validly, verifying it as the genuine and final testament of the deceased. Upon the testator’s passing, the executors named in the will may apply to the relevant court to seek probate, thereby establishing the will’s authenticity and executing the stipulated wishes of the deceased.
Understanding Probate
It is the legal procedure used to manage the estate of a deceased person, which encompasses validating the will, appointing and empowering the executor, and ensuring the appropriate distribution of assets and settlement of liabilities. This process is essential whether there is a will (with a named executor) or no will (requiring an administrator) and is overseen by the probate court. The responsibilities of this court include validating the will, appointing the executor, and authorizing them to manage and distribute the estate’s assets while also settling any remaining debts, such as funeral expenses, medical bills, taxes, and other outstanding liabilities.
However, undergoing probate can be costly. The expenses can be significant and vary depending on the estate’s complexity and any disputes that may arise regarding the will. These costs typically include court fees, attorney fees, and the expenses associated with filing notices to creditors, all under the supervision of a court judge.
When is Probate Mandatory?
In India, the legal framework for the probate of wills made by Hindus is outlined in the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (ISA). This act specifies certain conditions under which obtaining it is considered mandatory. Despite this, the term “mandatory” can be misleading; the ISA does not suggest that a will is invalid without probate. Instead, it is considered valid unless proven otherwise. However, for executors to establish their rights and for the title transfer to legatees to be complete, probate must be obtained. Without that, the completion of title to properties bequeathed by the will remains incomplete, potentially complicating the executor’s or legatee’s legal standing.
Specifically, under the Indian Succession Act 1925, probate is mandatory when all of the following conditions are met:
Registered and Unregistered Wills: Is Probate Necessary?
- Registered Wills
Not all wills require registration, and registration itself merely verifies the identity of the will’s creator and the witnesses. Importantly, the law does not mandate probate for registered wills. In cases where there is no dispute among legal heirs about the will’s contents, the heirs might opt to forego probate, making the process more straightforward.
- Unregistered Wills
The Indian Succession Act of 1925 does not require probate for unregistered wills; however, specific regional rules may dictate otherwise. For example, in Delhi’s National Capital Region (NCR), a government circular states that an unregistered will does not constitute proof of ownership, necessitating probate to implement the will properly.
Can a Will be Executed without Probate?
When dealing with the execution of wills, particularly in India, the question often arises: Can a will be executed without probate? Generally, obtaining it is advisable and becomes necessary when dealing with immovable property. According to the Indian Succession Act of 1925, probate is mandatory if a will has been made by a Hindu, Sikh, Jain, or Buddhist within the territories of what was formerly undivided Bengal or within the jurisdictions of the High Courts of Madras or Bombay. Furthermore, if a will pertains to property located within these areas but is made elsewhere in India, probate remains compulsory.
Comparison Between Will with Probate and Will without Probate
| Aspect | With | Without |
| Privacy | Public record | Private |
| Speed | Time-consuming | Faster resolution |
| Cost | Potentially high due to fees | Generally lower expenses |
| Legal Oversight | Supervised by the Court | No official supervision |
| Dispute Risk | Lower (court resolves) | Higher risk without oversight |
Right Choice For You
Deciding whether to plan your estate to include or bypass probate depends on your individual circumstances, the complexity of your assets, and your wishes for how you’d like your estate handled after your death. Consulting with a lawyer or estate planner can provide personalized advice based on your specific situation.
At Mitt Arv, we believe in empowering you to secure your legacy with confidence. Our comprehensive Asset Vault simplifies estate planning, ensuring all your assets are meticulously organized and your wishes honored. With Mitt Arv by your side, you can create a seamless and stress-free transition for your loved ones, safeguarding their future while preserving your peace of mind.
Available on Android, iOS & Web.
FAQs
- What is probate, and why is it necessary?
It is the legal process that validates a will and oversees the distribution of a deceased person’s assets. It ensures that the will is authentic, appoints an executor to manage the estate, and facilitates the transfer of assets to beneficiaries.
- Is probate mandatory for all wills in India?
No, it is not mandatory for all wills. It is required for wills executed within West Bengal, Chennai, or Mumbai by Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, or Buddhists, especially when the will involves movable and immovable property within these jurisdictions.
- Do registered wills always require probate?
Not necessarily. While registration confirms the identity of the will’s creator, probate is generally not required if there is no dispute among the heirs. However, in cases involving property titles or complex estates, probate may still be necessary.
- Can unregistered wills be executed without probate?
Execution of unregistered wills without probate depends on regional laws. For instance, in Delhi NCR, probate is necessary to implement an unregistered will as proof of ownership for property transfer.
- What are the main differences between wills with and without probate?
Wills with probate are subject to court supervision, making them public records, but they provide legal oversight and reduce disputes. Wills without probate remain private and may resolve faster but carry higher risks of disputes and lack official validation.